Act 1[]
- Jeremy's Theme - Be More Chill Band
- More Than Survive - Jeremy Heere, Michael Mell, Be More Chill Ensemble
- I Love Play Rehearsal - Christine Canigula
- The Squip Song - Rich Goranski, Be More Chill Ensemble
- Two-Player Game - Jeremy Heere, Michael Mell
- The Squip Enters - The Squip
- Be More Chill (Pt. 1) - The Squip, Jeremy Heere, Be More Chill Ensemble
- Do You Wanna Ride? - Brooke Lohst, Chloe Valentine
- Be More Chill (Pt. 2) - The Squip, Jeremy Heere, Be More Chill Ensemble
- More Than Survive (Reprise) - Jeremy Heere, Be More Chill Ensemble
- ☓Sync Up - The Squip, Jeremy Heere, Be More Chill Ensemble
- A Guy That I'd Kinda Be Into - Christine Canigula, Be More Chill Ensemble
- The Squip Lurks - Be More Chill Band
- Upgrade - Be More Chill Ensemble
- ✦Loser Geek Whatever - Jeremy Heere
Act 2[]
- Halloween - Be More Chill Ensemble
- Do You Wanna Hang? - Chloe Valentine
- Michael In The Bathroom - Michael Mell
- A Guy That I'd Kinda Be Into (Reprise) - Jeremy Heere, Christine Canigula
- The Smartphone Hour (Rich Set a Fire) - Jenna Rolan, Brooke Lohst, Chloe Valentine, Be More Chill Ensemble
- ✝︎The Pitiful Children - The Squip, Be More Chill Ensemble
- ✝︎The Pants Song - Jeremy's Dad, Michael Mell
- The Play - Jeremy Heere, Michael Mell, Be More Chill Ensemble
- Voices In My Head - Jeremy Heere, Christine Canigula, Be More Chill Ensemble
✝︎ - During the Off-Broadway and Broadway production, the order of 'The Pitiful Children' and 'The Pants Song' were reversed.
☓ - 'Sync Up' replaced 'More Than Survive (Reprise)' in the Broadway production
✦ - Added to the Off-Broadway and Broadway production
Listen to the band talk to the hosts of Broadwaysted, in an the episode The Be More Chill The Band Gets Broadwaysted!